Derek Schiller President & CEO, Atlanta Braves | Atlanta Braves Website
Derek Schiller President & CEO, Atlanta Braves | Atlanta Braves Website
The southpaw is surging across MLB. Last season, there was a lull for left-handers, with only one (the Cubs’ Justin Steele) finishing among the top 10 in FanGraphs’ version of pitcher WAR. While then-Padres lefty Blake Snell did take NL Cy Young honors, only two of his compatriots were also among the 20 AL or NL pitchers to receive votes for the award (Framber Valdez was ninth in the AL; Steele was fifth in the NL).
In 2024, it’s a different story entirely. Heading into Wednesday, southpaws took up six of the top 10 spots in fWAR, and they landed in five of the top 10 spots in our latest Starting Pitcher Power Rankings. Three lefties have combined to lead this poll four consecutive times, going back to May 23.
Here are the latest Starting Pitcher Power Rankings, with our MLB.com panel once again considering career track record, season-long performance and recent success. (All stats are through Tuesday’s games.)
1. Tarik Skubal, Tigers (Last poll: 2)
Skubal has factored into every edition of these rankings in 2024, with five straight appearances in the top two. This is his second time in the No. 1 spot. The 27-year-old has more than made good on his considerable hype as a preseason breakout candidate and looks like a clear AL Cy Young Award favorite. Skubal came off the injured list to make his 2023 debut exactly one year ago, and in roughly a full season’s worth of work since then (32 starts), he’s gone 16-6 with a 2.60 ERA, 165 ERA+ and 221 strikeouts.
2. Corbin Burnes, Orioles (4)
Burnes dipped as low as ninth in these rankings in late May but has been trending upward again. Baltimore’s ace has been absolutely as advertised following an offseason trade from Milwaukee: a durable, consistent and productive starter for a team with championship aspirations. Burnes has pitched at least five innings in each of his 17 outings (and gone six-plus 14 times), and only once has he allowed more than three runs. The highest his ERA has climbed after any start this year? 2.83.
3. Garrett Crochet, White Sox(8)
Two questions loom over Crochet’s phenomenal season: How many more innings will he throw as a 25-year-old converted reliever with minimal workloads in his past? Will the White Sox trade him before the July 30 Deadline? No matter the answers to those questions, what Crochet has accomplished thus far is nothing short of astonishing. The AL Pitcher of the Month for June leads the AL in FIP (2.37), strikeouts (141) and K/9 rate (12.5).
4. Paul Skenes, Pirates (7)
How do you know things are going well for Skenes so far? He didn’t have his best stuff last Saturday at Atlanta yet still gutted through six innings while allowing just one run and striking out nine in only his ninth career start. Afterward, his manager called it “a big learning moment” for how he made adjustments.
5. Seth Lugo, Royals (not ranked)
One could argue that our voting panel has been slow to warm up to Lugo’s excellent season given his age (34) and relatively light track record of MLB success as a starting pitcher. But after signing a two-year $30 million deal with the Royals this past offseason, Lugo has delivered beyond expectations. He leads the Majors in wins (11), innings pitched (116), ERA (2.17), ERA+ (196) and Baseball Reference’s version of pitcher WAR (4.2).
6. Zack Wheeler, Phillies (6)
If Wheeler has slowed down a bit since his dominant start to the season it’s not by much. While the Orioles did knock him around for four homers and eight earned runs on June 16 at Camden Yards that was his only hiccup over an eight-start span entering Wednesday's outing in Chicago.
7.Tyler Glasnow,Dodgers(9)
The righty looks set for his first All-Star selection.Before throwing his first pitch of July Glasnow is only four starts away from matching career highs.His unprecedented durability has been huge for Dodgers dealing with injuries.
8.Ranger Suárez Phillies(1)
Suárez rose all way to No1 but allowed ten runs(eight earned)with only four strikeouts over ten innings.Clearly,the soft-tossing lefty wasn’t going keep up early-season pace but still leads NL wins(ten)ERA(2)
9.Chris Sale Braves(not ranked)
Sale rejuvenation this season--at age thirty-five coming off years injury-related frustration--has been impressive.The MLB leader FIP(232)is serious Cy Young contender.After isolated blowup against A's Sale posted ERA
10.Max Fried Braves(not ranked)
That two Atlanta lefties close out top ten.Fried set become free agent after this making strong contract push.Going back shutout against Miami Fried multiple complete games
Others receiving votes:Cristopher Sánchez Phillies Logan Gilbert Mariners George Kirby Mariners Cole Ragans Royals Tanner Houck Red Sox Hunter Brown Astros Reynaldo López Braves Sonny Gray Cardinals Gavin Stone Dodgers Ronel Blanco Astros
Voters: Chris Begley Jason Catania Theo DeRosa Daniel Feldman Brian Murphy Sweeny Murti Efrain Ruiz Shanthi Sepe-Chepuru Andrew Simon Ismail Soyugenc David Venn Tom Vourtsis